Recently we came across a new reason not to talk to the police which is that they could be secretly recording you on their mobile phones. A recording which is made unlawfully and stored insecurely, with the sole intent of being used as potential evidence at a later date.
According to this discussion on a police forum it appears that some serving officers record members of the public on their mobile phones on the off-chance (or so they claim) that a complaint is made about them. That way, should someone give a different account of what was actually said, the officer can supposedly produce the recording as evidence to help him avoid any charges of misconduct.
This type of covert surveillance was discussed on the UK Police Online forums under the following question:
What if you have a meeting as a complainant against police at your home address and the officers who attend record your conversation on their personal mobile phones (in their stab vest) allegedly in order to fully document their pocketbooks verbatim without you knowing they were recording you at the time this was happening.
With regards to the data once transcribed into their pocket notebooks it was to be deleted by the officers
This has only been found out retrospectively.
Is there a offence here? Could the officers get disciplined or sacked?
Several replies followed. The first of which was from a serving police officer:
I have done it before, when believing that a complainant might make a complaint against me and not wishing to sit with a camera in their face on the off chance they are totally fine. It wasnt evidential and only kept for a few days to see if there was a complaint coming.
It shouldnt really be used to record things for them to update their notebooks after but its hardly a crime or that bad, unless they are making stuff up, which they would be able to do without recording it.
I doubt they could be sacked. Im assuming that you want them disciplined in some way?
This was then followed by another member asking the relevant questions:
Is this not a breach of human rights?
Breach of data protection?
Breach of PACE?
Another serving officer replied to those questions with the following:
However the answers given are wrong. The correct answers should be:
No. (But a breach of RIPA)
Why the police cannot record the public for their own personal use
A police officer covertly recording a conversation on the off-chance the subject might make a complaint is excessive gathering of data. It is unnecessary and intrusive and certainly engages Article 8 of the Human Rights Act: Right to respect for private and family life. This is a somewhat high-handed approach though as the Human Rights Act should only be applied when no other remedy at law exists. And such a remedy does exist in the form of the Data Protection Act.
It’s true that when an individual records another for a domestic purpose (including the use of home CCTV) they are not subject to any data protection laws. You and I may record a police officer on our phones whenever we wish without their knowledge or permission. They on the other hand do not share the same rights. They are agents of the state, and any information gathered during the execution of their duties makes them subject to the same data protection laws as every other state official. It doesn’t matter WHY a police officer is recording, all that matters is whether or not the recording can be classed as personal data.
In this instance, the police officer may think that he is making the recording for a domestic purpose. It is after all his personal mobile phone and it’s not a police interview. But talking to anyone during the execution of his duties would be classed as police business. He is not socialising with these potential complainants. He is on duty. In uniform. Carrying the full weight of office that no doubt affords him to speak to such people in the first place. Therefore any recording made would be subject to the same data protection and surveillance laws as any other means of gathering police data. The fact that he made the recording on his own mobile phone for his own protection or note-taking is irrelevant.
Even if a recording is deleted it could still be classed as stored data
Any type of surveillance or communication equipment used by the police to make recordings is subject to home office approval before it can be used. Evidential purposes aside, safeguards are also put in place to ensure that sensitive personal information is stored securely and can be destroyed effectively. Just how secure would such sensitive data be on a police officers personal phone? A phone that he will no doubt take back home which he shares with other family members. A phone that could be mislaid or stolen. Notwithstanding the fact that the phone app used to record the conversation could also be insecure. Would you be happy knowing that your personal data was carried around in a police officer’s pocket on and off duty?
The suggestion in the original question that the recording is destroyed right after an officer transcribes it into his notebook is of course a red herring. The officer has no intention of doing any such thing. How would anyone know that the notebook transcription is correct if there is no recording to back it up? And even if the recording was being made as a memory aid, that would mean that police officers could be routinely secretly recording interactions with members of the public whenever they choose, just to make it easier to write it up later in their pocket books.
Regardless of whether they delete the recording promptly or not the information could still be easily restored. It has already been demonstrated in rulings made by the ICO that personal data that can be easily restored once deleted is still treated as stored data and remains subject in full to data protection. This means that the officer could be carrying the deleted recording around with him in his pocket for years without ever realising he was still in breach of data protection laws.
How covert recordings can become a criminal offence
Breaching the data protection act in this manner is a criminal offence. Covert recording by the police for personal use is a serious act of misconduct which is not only a sackable offence, could land an officer in jail.
Although it is not a breach of the Police and Criminal Evidence Act, it would be a breach of the Regulation of Investigatory Powers Act 2000 (RIPA) which legislates against such state intrusion. As recording a potential complainant in this way is neither necessary on one of the grounds set out in section 28(3) or proportionate, then no authority to covertly record could be given or implied and the force concerned would have no protection under this Act.
How to report the police for recording on their mobile phones
If you should ever discover that the police have used any such covert means to record you (or anyone else) on their mobile phones, then you should make a complaint to the Investigatory Powers Tribunal. This Tribunal is a court which investigates and determines complaints of unlawful use of covert techniques by public authorities and law enforcement agencies that infringe our right to privacy or breaches our human rights.
Furthermore you can make a subject access request to the relevant force for a copy of any such unlawful recordings made by a named officer. Should such a recording exist, you can make a complaint under the Data Protection Act by contacting the Information Commissioners Office and potentially bring a claim for damages in the County Court.
For detailed information on how to defeat the police complaint’s process, as well as how to make a claim for compensation without having to use a solicitor or go to court, then please consider purchasing our Ebook “Take on the Police and Win“:
For just £4.50 this Ebook will equip you with almost everything you need to know on how to challenge the police and get an effective outcome from the complaints, appeal and compensation process, including:
- How to bring claims for false imprisonment, assault, trespass, malicious prosecution and other civil wrongs
- How to defeat the police complaints process
- How to obtain payouts from the police without going to court
- How to prevent the police from sabotaging your complaint
- Complaint and claim letter templates
- A comprehensive guide on obtaining professional legal help for free
- The e-mail addresses of every police complaint department in England and Wales
You can purchase this Ebook for instant download as a .PDF document which will open on all laptops, smart phones, tablets, Ereaders, Desktops and laptops.
Just click on the Paypal link to purchase and download your copy immediately for just £4.50.
By purchasing any of our Ebooks you will be helping fund this site and keep it alive.
Our most sincere thanks to all of those who have done so over the years and given us such excellent feedback. This site exists because of you.